This resource has been prepared for educational purposes only. This information is current as of the date of writing and does not constitute legal, investment or other professional advice, which should be obtained prior to relying on anything herein.
____________________________________________________________________________
In Ontario securities law, the concept of the “business trigger” is crucial in determining when an individual or company must register with the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC). It’s a threshold that helps identify whether a person or entity’s activities in the securities market qualify as a business requiring regulatory oversight. Understanding the business trigger is essential for anyone trading or advising on securities in Ontario, as engaging in securities business without registration can result in significant penalties. In this article, we’ll explore what the business trigger is, how it applies, and what it means for market participants.
What is the Business Trigger?
The business trigger is a legal threshold that determines when an activity involving securities, such as advising or trading, must be conducted by a registered individual or firm. Simply put, if someone is in the business of trading or advising in securities, they must register with the OSC or qualify for an exemption. Registration ensures that individuals and firms meet the qualifications, integrity, and oversight necessary to protect investors and uphold market integrity.
To determine if a person or entity’s activities meet the business trigger, the OSC considers factors such as frequency, commercial purpose, and whether compensation is received. The business trigger helps prevent unqualified or unlicensed individuals from providing financial advice or selling securities, thereby protecting the public from potential harm.
Why Does the Business Trigger Exist?
The business trigger exists to:
1. Protect Investors: Registration is a safeguard to ensure that anyone advising or trading in securities has met rigorous qualification standards and follows regulatory requirements.
2. Maintain Market Integrity: Registered individuals and firms are subject to the OSC’s compliance and enforcement actions, which promote fair, transparent, and ethical practices in Ontario’s securities markets.
3. Define Regulatory Boundaries: By establishing clear criteria for when registration is required, the business trigger provides clarity for market participants, helping them understand their regulatory obligations.
Determining the Business Trigger: Key Factors
The OSC uses several criteria to assess whether someone is in the business of trading or advising in securities. No single factor is determinative; instead, the OSC looks at the entire picture to make an assessment. Here are the primary factors considered:
1. Engaging in Activities with Repetition or Regularity:
Regular or repeated securities activities are strong indicators that registration is required. For example, if someone frequently sells investment products or provides ongoing securities advice, it’s likely they are considered to be “in the business.”
Occasional or one-time activities may not meet the business trigger. However, when such activities become routine, they are more likely to require registration.
2. Expectation of Profit:
If securities activities are conducted with the goal of making a profit, the business trigger is likely met. For instance, individuals or entities compensated for advising or trading in securities, even if indirectly, are generally subject to registration.
This factor also applies to those who receive referral fees or commissions based on the investment decisions of clients. Any form of compensation tied to securities activities could indicate a business purpose.
3. Soliciting Securities Transactions:
Actively soliciting clients to buy, sell, or invest in securities is a strong indicator of the business trigger. Marketing or advertising securities-related services, contacting potential clients, and promoting securities transactions to the public are common examples of solicitation.
Solicitation can include both direct and indirect efforts, such as networking events, seminars, or even online advertising that promotes securities-related services.
4. Directly or Indirectly Holding Out as Being in the Securities Business:
Representing oneself as being in the business of advising or trading in securities is a key factor. Examples include using titles like “investment advisor” or “portfolio manager” without registration or promoting oneself as an investment expert.
Even informal statements, such as offering “investment advice” or publicly discussing specific securities, could be viewed as “holding out,” especially if they create an expectation that advice or trading will be ongoing.
5. Providing Specific Recommendations:
Offering specific investment recommendations or advice tailored to individual clients indicates the need for registration. If someone is providing detailed securities advice or suggesting specific securities to clients, they are likely engaging in regulated activity.
General discussions or educational content, without direct recommendations, typically do not meet the business trigger. However, as soon as advice becomes specific and personalized, registration may be required.
6. Other Business-Like Characteristics:
Additional business-like attributes, such as operating through a company or maintaining a client list, are further indicators of being in the securities business. Firms that maintain client records, establish a fee schedule, or conduct securities business through structured entities are more likely to be subject to registration requirements.
Examples of Activities That May Trigger Registration
Understanding whether registration is required depends on the specific context, but here are some common scenarios where the business trigger might apply:
• Financial Advisors: Individuals who frequently provide investment advice, especially if they charge fees or commissions, must register. For example, a financial planner recommending mutual funds or other securities must be registered with the OSC.
• Investment Clubs: Groups where members pool money to buy securities can sometimes trigger registration requirements. If an individual within the club is providing specific securities advice for compensation, they may need to register.
• Referral Programs: Anyone earning fees for referring clients to a securities dealer or advisor may need to register, especially if the referrals are frequent or there is an expectation of ongoing compensation.
• Trading Platforms: Online platforms facilitating securities transactions or providing advice might trigger the need for registration, particularly if they solicit clients or receive compensation related to trading activities.
• Real Estate Crowdfunding: Real estate crowdfunding platforms that pool investor funds for property investments and distribute securities may require registration if they are engaging in ongoing investment solicitation and advice.
Exemptions to the Business Trigger Requirement
Ontario securities law provides certain exemptions to the registration requirement for people and businesses that meet the business trigger. Here are a few common exemptions:
1. Incidental Advice Exemption:
Professionals like accountants, lawyers, and engineers who occasionally provide investment advice as part of their core services may qualify for this exemption, provided that the advice is truly incidental to their primary service.
2. International Dealers and Advisors:
Dealers and advisors from outside Canada can operate in Ontario under certain conditions, such as only advising specific institutional clients. They must be registered in their home jurisdiction and meet additional regulatory requirements.
3. Private Issuers:
Private companies that sell securities only to friends, family, business associates, and accredited investors, and do not publicly solicit investments, may not meet the business trigger, especially if transactions are occasional and have no commercial intent.
Consequences of Failing to Register
If an individual or firm meets the business trigger but fails to register, the consequences can be severe. The OSC can impose penalties, revoke licenses, and restrict business operations. Additionally, failing to register can expose market participants to legal liabilities, as any transactions conducted without proper registration may be considered invalid, potentially leading to investor claims or lawsuits.
How to Determine If You Meet the Business Trigger
If you’re unsure whether your activities meet the business trigger, here are a few steps to consider:
1. Consult a Securities Lawyer: A securities lawyer can help clarify whether your activities require registration and advise on compliance with Ontario securities laws.
2. Review OSC Guidance: The OSC regularly publishes guidance on activities that may require registration. Reviewing this information can provide insights into whether your business model requires registration.
3. Consider Your Business Model: Examine how frequently you engage in securities activities, whether you expect to earn compensation, and whether you advertise or solicit clients. If any of these are present, you may be close to meeting the business trigger.
Conclusion: Navigating the Business Trigger for Registration in Ontario
Understanding the business trigger is essential for anyone involved in securities activities in Ontario. It serves as an important guideline to help ensure only qualified professionals are advising on and trading securities, thus protecting investors and upholding the integrity of Ontario’s capital markets. For those considering whether they need to register, understanding the OSC’s criteria for the business trigger can help clarify their regulatory responsibilities and avoid legal pitfalls. If your activities might meet the business trigger, registering with the OSC is the best way to ensure compliance and protect both your clients and your business. By following Ontario securities law, you contribute to a safer, more transparent investment environment that benefits everyone involved.